patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Another Giant? Why?

Giant already operates 17 stores within a 10-mile radius of Newtown. So why would it want to operate yet another in the Village at Newtown Shopping Center?

 

 

Another Giant? Why?

That’s the question that many around town are asking after Giant announced last week it will be taking over the local Genuardi’s by the middle of the year.

Giant, a supermarket chain headquartered in Carlisle, plans to purchase 16 Genuardi’s stores in the Greater Philadelphia region, including the one in the Village at Newtown Shopping Center. The $106 million transaction also includes Genuardi’s stores in Langhorne, Jamison, Chalfont and West Chester.

The fact that Giant already operates 17 stores within a 10-mile radius of Newtown – one just two miles away from the current Genuardi's – has caused many to wonder why the supermarket is seeking to open even more locations in the area.

Based on the more than 45 comments on Patch’s previous coverage of the story, it seems many residents were hopeful a Whole Foods was preparing to occupy the space. But the Whole Foods rumor was just that – and now many are frustrated by they foresee will be a lack of grocery store variety in the area.

Some members of the community have speculated that perhaps the store will change hands again after the deal is completed. But that, according to Giant spokesman Christopher Brand, is simply not the case.

“We expect to operate all 16 stores as Giant food stores,” Brand said of the deal with Genuardi’s.

Based on the comments, it seems many residents were hopeful some variety would be coming to the area.

“Wegmans or Trader Joes or Whole Foods would be fantastic. Giant is very disappointing,” wrote one Patch user.

“I'd also prefer a Trader Joe's, Wegmanns or Whole Foods over Giant. Why would they want to have two stores about one mile apart? Makes no sense,” wrote another Patch user.

But Brand said it’s not uncommon for the supermarket chain to seek to operate several stores in one area.  “Our goal is always to provide stores and to grow our business to serve our customers,” he said. 

Giant recently completed a renovation of its store off the Newtown Bypass in the Summit Square Shopping Center and currently operates stores in Yardley, New Hope, Levittown, Southampton, Morrisville and more.

“Certainly it’s our aim to provide convenient locations for our customers because we represent what we believe is a one-stop shop,” Brand said.

Related Topics: Genuardi's, Giant Food Store, and Newtown Business News

Mar

2:20 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

One more Giant = one more Giant I will not be shopping at. I guess this is good news for Acme and the other grocery stores in the area.

Reply

Dana - www.petsitnewtown.com

3:30 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

I don't like Giant at all. I think that Giant is a lower-end food store in my opinion, vs. Acme, etc. and I think that those who shop Genuardi's currently won't be interested in shopping at Giant, so Acme will get more business.

Reply

cstone

3:41 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

In the marketing world it's called having a Monopoly! Smart on Giant's end but the consumers should be outraged!

Reply

Becky Evans

4:13 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

The only way to get them to leave is not to shop there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

MR

7:25 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Boycott- it's the only way!!

MBZ

10:12 pm on Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Why do people always think Wegmans is going to move into their old stores? Wegmans operates large, built-from-the-ground-up stores (120,000+ sq. feet). Variety would be nice, but anything is better than an empty retail space in a busy shopping center.

Reply

Betsy Hunt

12:29 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

I'll keep driving to Princeton...and Warrington...for Whole Foods

Reply
Comment_arrow

angel

10:39 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

me too! like whole foods! wegmans prices are consistantly lower than g, g, and a! local produce shops are good for fresh veggies too

Lisa

7:36 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

I guess I too will need to investigate what else is around. I didn't like Giant before it was renovated and while now it is very pretty, I still don't like it. Nothing again Acme, but I don't like they way the stock their shelves, you can find a product in three different places in that store, none where you think it might be. Plus it is cold looking and large. But I will most likely go there until I find my new spot. I guess Giant has a huge task in front of them of winning over us loyal Genuardi Customers. Are they up to the task?

Reply
Comment_arrow

James Mayer

8:04 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

Just think of Clemens. 13 stores were bought and converted to Giant and honestly I am very happy for that. I was speaking to a Clemens now Giant employee and she said that Clemens was nice, but Giant has better benefits and what not for their employees. Giant won me over from Clemens. The name is changing and yes the store brands are changing as well, but that's really it. You can still buy everyday items there and I gaurentee you'll still see the same employees.

Stevi

9:06 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

I was very pleased when Richboro voted down a new Giant in town, now I'm sad that Newtown will be inflicted with not one but TWO. At the rate that Giant is expanding they seem to want to be the ONLY grocery store option for ALL the customers which is both foolish and impossible. I greatly dislike Giant's stores, their product selection, their low quality meats... There are reasons I avoid the TWELVE STORES within 5 miles of my house... and now they're adding 3 more?! <sigh>

Reply
Comment_arrow

angel

10:40 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

they will get away with 2 because technically they will be located in 2 different towns-langhorne and newtown :/

pamela

10:34 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Giant...sigh...another Giant, really? I will not shop at their stores, I did once, it was enough. The drive to Wegman's is worth my time, gas, money and energy. I also smell Monopoly in the air. I suppose that the only way they can get customers is to be the only option in town.

Reply
Comment_arrow

James Mayer

8:12 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

Lets think here. Only 1 Giant has closed due to low sales in the last 15 years. That to me shows that they know what they're doing. Also, this monopoly you smell isn't really one at all. More and more stores are selling groceries now. Target, CVS, Rite Aid, Dollar stores, need I go on? All them weren't selling groceries (or at least as much as they do now) 10 years ago. So if there's a CVS down the street selling grocery items, that's not a monopoly since Giant has items that CVS sells and vise versa. And speaking of drug stores, when you see 2 CVS stores on the same street within 2 minutes of eachother, do you scream "MONOPOLY!!" I think everyone needs to calm down. It's just a grocery store.

angel

10:43 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

anyone want to start a sustainable, organic co-op? we could use a report about the local cattle raisers, too

Reply

MR

12:24 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

An organic, local co-op would be divine... Or a Whole Foods! In the meantime, I will continue to support the Whole Foods in Princeton, The Grape Vine in Newtown, and Earth Foods in Buckingham...

Reply
Comment_arrow

MR

1:58 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Earth Foods is located at 4950 York Rd, Holicong (sorry, I said Buckingham before)... It's a very small store, but they do carry some good products. It's similar to the Grape Vine although they do not sell any produce...

Joanne

6:18 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Sadly communities have very little to say about the commercial operations in their towns, thanks to PA state laws that favor developers and big corporations. Newtown has an additional problem thanks to how often our zoning board prostitutes itself to any business that asks for variances. This is what you get with "business friendly Republicsns" in charge for decade after decade.

Reply

Hmmmm

8:54 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Competition at the same level will be good for pricing and service. Look, I'd love a Wegman's but it isn't happening. Let the free market determine our options.

Reply
Comment_arrow

MR

9:56 am on Friday, January 13, 2012

It's not a "free market" if one store has a monopoly on the selection.

Ellen

10:21 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Big Bear Natural Foods! There's one in Lambertville and one on Route 1 next to the Lowe's. It's no Whole Foods or Trader Joes but they have a decent selection of fresh and packaged organic healthy foods.

Reply

Hmmmm

10:20 am on Friday, January 13, 2012

How is it a monopoly when the competition (Acme) is 500 feet away? A free market is a competitive market and that's exactly what we have and should want.

Reply
Comment_arrow

MR

5:11 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

The thing that you are missing is there is no true difference between the selection or the pricing at the Acme and the Giant. It's basically like having two identical stores in the same shopping center. A Whole Foods would actually provide variety and choice. And, not to mention, the number of other Giant stores that are taking over the area... one store with a different name and the exact same merchandise, the Acme, doesn't really make the " free market" that you speak of very effective.

Hmmmm

10:40 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

For those who shop on price, Giant is much better than Acme. For those who shop at leisure for prepared food selection and/or "organic", when price or time isn't an issue for you, there are plenty of close options.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Linda McFadden

1:17 am on Sunday, January 15, 2012

I agree, Prices at Giant are much better than Acme or Genuardis. Shop and Bag in Richboro even has better prices than the Acme or Genuardis. And I have read several comments saying Giant is low end, but who cares, Food is expensive now, gotta love the lower prices

Ellen

9:29 am on Saturday, January 14, 2012

There is a winter Farmer's Market in Wrightstown today, if anyone wants fresh, local produce go check it out. It's in the field next to the Wrightstown Municipal Building on Route 232.

Reply

LA

1:54 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

Just found this email address for TJ's and sent them a begging email. Maybe if a lot of us requested their presence in Newtown, they'd pay attention.

http://www.traderjoes.com/about/general-feedback-form.asp

Reply

angel

4:30 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

monoply or not, food isn't what it it use to be or should be. too many money-hungry people involved (government, labs, etc). there is no flavor in many veggies and fruits(even when i harvest seedlings that i plant in my backyard). that is because they are coming from manufactured seed labs that produce artifically, genetically modified versions. it's like eating fake food. now i have to look for organic, natural varieties to plant. the big stores don't care what they offer us they care about making money from us.

Reply

Hmmmm

9:00 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

Whole Foods cares as much about making money as Acme or Giant. They just do a better job making you feel good about it.

Reply

angel

11:11 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

true. still like wegman's and wf these days:) happy shopping!

Reply

Gerry Couch

11:49 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

One Giant was plenty! Maybe if we boycott both of them they will go away! I don't think Giant Lot is large enough to accomadate a Wegmans. I was dissapointed when Safe- way bought Genaurdi's now Giant buys them, that is pretty much the end of the line.

Reply

MR

9:28 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

Of course Whole Foods cares about making money just as much as the Acme or Giant- that's what makes them a viable business. They are able to make their customers feel good about it because they sell better products which makes them worth every extra penny spent. Newtown is such a great little town with quite a lot going for it. It's just too bad that our only shopping choices are going to be two Giant stores and an Acme and that so many of us will be traveling to other towns so we can shop at Whole Foods (or Wegman's).

Reply

Joe

3:12 pm on Monday, January 16, 2012

Giant is a Pennsylvania based store chain. It's a good thing to support local businesses. Giant is a large employer of local folks also. I'm sure if enough people mention to Giant Managemant what they would like to see in their store, Giant would have to respond to customer demands. Wegmans and Whole Foods have great specialty items but are also pricey.

Reply

Leave a comment